Making a really good meatless rendition of Sichuan mapo tofu has eluded me for years. Many of the versions I’ve tried used mushroom to mimic the ground beef or pork. The result was texturally off. I’d tried combining shiitake with white mushroom but it was so strong tasting, woodsy more than anything else. Plus, the mushroom cooked up dark, making the dish totally not like regular mapo tofu. The savory depth and richness of the ground meat that’s used in mapo tofu was missing.
Then there’s the use of weak chile bean sauce. You really need the punchy stuff from Sichuan if you want to makes something that can stand shoulder to shoulder with the conventional version of mapo tofu.
I was looking for a result that looked and tasted quite similar to the real deal. I was looking for a dish that could satisfy by culinarily punking your eyes and palate. That is no easy feat. I know that because I've been trying and thinking for some time.
While cleaning my office last week, I came across a Chinese vegetarian cookbook that employed tofu skin and shiitake mushroom to mimic the ground meat in mapo tofu. It didn’t sound quite like what I was looking for in a fake ground meat, but it did trigger this idea: Freeze, thaw, then crumble up some tofu!
I'd frozed leftover tofu before I headed to Asia in December so there was a stash to experiment with. After I combined it it with a little shiitake mushroom and dark soy sauce, I had a pretty good facsimile of ground meat.
The recipe below arose from a couple of rounds of tinkering in the kitchen. It visually and texturally looks like mapo tofu. Flavorwise, it has umami oomp from soy sauce as well as fermented bean sauce. My husband, who adores the classic version with ground beef, approved with a political joke: “Send this to Bill Clinton!” (My husband teaches political science and Clinton turn vegan a while ago.) We ate more than half of this batch below for dinner and then he took leftovers for lunch.
How does vegan mapo tofu differ from the regular mapo tofu?
There are subtle differences between the vegan mapo tofu approach and the traditional version that’s in the Asian Tofu cookbook. Doing a clear straight sub for the beef or pork didn't work. I made subtle tweaks because the thawed tofu absorbs and reflects back the seasonings much more strongly than the beef.
P.S. If you can't get the Pixian chile bean sauce, add a quarter or half teaspoon of chile flakes to the wok for heat. My frozen tofu was from Whole Foods. The cubed tofu was Trader Joe's regular tofu.
Vegan Mapo Tofu
Yields: 4 servings
Ingredients
- 3 dried shiitake mushrooms
- 5 to 6 ounces (150 to 180 g) frozen extra-firm tofu
- ¾ teaspoon dark soy sauce
- 16 ounces (450 g) medium or medium-firm tofu
- Generous 1 teaspoon Sichuan peppercorns
- 1 rounded teaspoon minced ginger
- 3 tablespoons chile bean sauce, Pixian kind preferred
- About 1 teaspoon sugar
- ½ to 1 teaspoon regular soy sauce
- 2 to 3 tablespoons canola oil
- 1 tablespoon cornstarch diluted in 2 to 3 tablespoons water
- 1 or 2 large green onions, green and white parts, cut on the diagonal
Method
- Soak the mushroom in water (hot, warm, or cold, depending on how much time you have) to rehydrate. Meanwhile, thaw the frozen tofu at room temperature.
- Trim the mushroom of the stems, then finely chop. Transfer to a bowl. Stand over a sink and squeeze on the tofu to expel most of the excess water – until it resembles a moist sponge. Crumble the tofu into the mushroom bowl; don’t make it too small because you want some texture. Add the dark soy sauce and stir well to combine. Set aside.
- Cut the tofu into ½-inch (1.25 cm) cubes and put into a bowl. Add enough just-boiled water to cover, then soak for 15 minutes. Meanwhile, measure out 1 ⅓ cups of water (the stuff you just boiled is fine) and set aside near the stove for later use.
- In a large wok or skillet, toast the peppercorn over medium heat for 2 to 3 minutes, until fragrant and slightly darkened. Cool briefly, then pound with a mortar and pestle or grind in a spice grinder. Set aside.
- Drain the tofu in a strainer or colander and set near the stove with the other ingredients.
- Heat the oil in the wok or skillet over high heat. Add the crumbled tofu and mushroom, and cook for 1 minute until glossy and aromatic. Add the ginger, and chile bean sauce. Cook for about 2 minutes, stirring constantly, until the ingredients are reddish-brown color. Add the sugar and regular soy sauce, stir to combine, then add the tofu.
- Gently stir or give the wok a shake to combine. Pour in the 1 ⅓ cups water you set aside earlier. Bring to a vigorous simmer, and cook for about 3 minutes to allow the tofu to absorb the flavors of the sauce.
- Taste the sauce and add a pinch of sugar, if needed. Add the green onion, stir, then add enough of the cornstarch slurry to thicken. Sprinkle in the ground peppercorn, restir to incorporate, then transfer to a shallow bowl. Let rest for 5 minutes to meld flavors before enjoying with lots of hot rice.
Related posts:
Ashley @ Big Flavors from a Tiny Kitchen
This looks wonderful - I love tofu dishes 🙂
Martin
Is their an online source for Pixian chile Bean sauce?
Littauer
Have you tried Kenji Lopez-Alt's version (Serious Eats)?
http://www.seriouseats.com/2013/02/vegan-food-mapo-tofu-vegetarian-sichuan.html
Suzette
"culinarily punking your eyes and palate." Best. Vegan. Line. Ever.
Andrea Nguyen
Thanks!
Andrea Nguyen
I've yet to find one. Sorry.
Andrea Nguyen
Kenji's recipe was overly involved for me. I've been to people's homes in Chengdu and seen that it's a really really simple dish. I've also had at one of the original locations in Chengdu. Mapo is homey fare and given that, I wanted stick to that spirit. Less can be more.
Andrea Nguyen
Glad you picked up on that!
Ana
I make Fuchsia Dunlop's version which starts off by frying a lot of ginger and garlic in the chilli sauce and on gentle heat. This builds the backbone of the flavour. Most of the times, I don't even bother with the meat, and I certainly don't miss it.
Andrea Nguyen
Yup, that's a great approach too!
Sab
Hi Andrea,
There are two kinds of tofu from your list. Do we crubmle the extra-firm or the medium firm tofu. Thank you 🙂
Andrea Nguyen
Hi Sab -- In the ingredient list, the extra-firm is the one that is frozen, thawed and crumbled. I list ingredients in order of use. I know, recipe reading takes a little deciphering. Enjoy!
kj24
posharpstore.com sells it at:
http://www.posharpstore.com/en-us/chengdu-chuanxiangmei-pixian-broad-bean-paste-22-lbs-p3735.aspx
$10 for 2.2 pounds.
Also found: http://www.amazon.com/Sichuan-Pixian-Xian-Broad-Paste/dp/B00A9OF6NS
Vickie
Andrea, my grandfather came from Chengdu and my grandmother from Xian married. So food was different in Taiwan before they moved to San Francisco to lived. The ma po tofu made at home use some rice vinegar in it and no ginger and chili flake. I always see it so many different way to make it so there no right or wrong but your way.
Joshua Hampton
This vegetarian mapo tofu recipe looks wonderful. I'm looking forward to getting my eyes and palate culinarily punked on this one. Thanks.
Andrea Nguyen
You are absolutely right, Vickie. I ate a home-cooked version that had no chile bean sauce but a ton of Sichuan peppercorn. The family used it to double as their dan dan noodle topping. Lots of elasticity in this dish. For me, it's a homey one -- that doesn't need to be overly fussy. I like to honor that notion.
Andrea Nguyen
Don't wait too long, Joshua! Dive in.
Maggie
I find the 'meatiest' type of tofu is the deep fried, puffy tofu, which I slice into strips. Dried shiitakes have a meaty chewiness, as do fresh oyster mushrooms. I love discovering interesting substitutes.
Maggie
Not traditional, but I think it would be delicious with purple sprouting broccoli and oyster mushrooms.
jorgebob28
I use a similar method in both my veggie versions of Chili and MaPo Tofu. Shiitake is rehydrated and along with Crimini mushrooms, chopped fairly finely. Then, I chop tofu into 1/4" square pieces which I deep-fry. These 3 ingredients are my meat substitute. The mushrooms get stir-fried then the deep-fried tofu is added. The rest of the prep is as normal.
Candice
Hi Andrea,
If I just use extra firm tofu w/out freezing/thawing it, will the dish still turn out?
Matthew
Hi Andrea! Can a curious mind ask what the Chinese vegetarian cookbook was? I'm on the hunt for one! I hope to make this soon. Your post on the Szechuan chili bean paste was helpful when I went to T&T, one of the Asian grocery markets here in Vancouver.
Andrea Nguyen
Boy, that was five years ago when I wrote that post. Rereading it, I couldn't remember what book it was. Maybe a Weichuan one? I don't know. Sorry!